There's a couple things I would like to elaborate on in regards to my response to John Erzar's article. First, I have nothing against the pep talk that was used by Coach Gilsky to try to motivate his team. If he said those words to his kids in the privacy of a halftime locker room--I think that's a reasonable motivational speech that any coach would make. However, for John Erzar to use those words as a quote in a newspaper article is beyond comprehension and really leads one to question his motivation. No coach in his right mind would ever want to say anything demeaning about another program in a public forum. If I were Coach Gilsky and read that quote in the paper, I would want to crawl in a hole.
The truth is, this article could have been written with the same effectiveness without the demeaning reference to the Warriors "laughing and giggling" at halftime. But for whatever reason, John Erzar felt a need to include this quote in the article. Perhaps this was his way of getting his shot in when the program was down.
It's fair game for jourmalists covering high school sports to talk about wins and losses, coaching strategies, great players and great games. It's even OK to write articles about the coaches. But when you use a quote in a newspaper article that demeans the character and integrity of a group of high school kids --I'm sorry. That crosses the line. What is particularly hurtful about this article is that we know our kids have worked hard, they compete hard, and are respectful to their opponents--so they don't deserve to be characterized in the Times Leader (Circulation of 36,000) as goons.
With all that adversity facing the team last week--How 'bout them Warriors! They made us all proud with their effort against Hanover.
|